Pixar’s chief creative officer Pete Docter did something quite rare in modern Hollywood. He put the brakes on an ideological joyride before it crashed into the box office. Speaking to the Wall Street Journal, Docter explained why the studio decided to rewrite Elio and remove the LGBTQ storyline that had been wedged into the plot. He said, “We’re making a movie, not hundreds of millions of dollars of therapy.” In that single sentence, he summarized what parents have been thinking for years as entertainment giants insist on injecting adult identity politics into children’s films.
Elio tells the story of a lonely kid who looks to the stars for friendship. According to reports, early audiences weren’t buying it. Test screenings were abysmal, with many viewers saying they wouldn’t even pay to see it in theaters. The studio’s leadership finally realized that the story wasn’t resonating. Docter responded by ordering a total overhaul, which led to the departure of the film’s original director, Adrian Molina. The decision wiped out a substantial portion of completed animation and reoriented the movie toward something closer to family friendly than viral hashtag.
After Molina’s exit, Madeline Sharafian and Domee Shi took over directing duties and stripped out every sign of the character’s implied sexuality. WSJ notes that earlier versions included Elio riding a pink bike and imagining a life with a male crush. Those details quietly disappeared from the new cut. Predictably, the move sparked outrage inside Pixar’s own ranks and compounded staff frustration over Disney’s earlier decision to remove a transgender side character from Win or Lose. When it finally launched in 2025, Elio managed to pull in $150 million worldwide—the same number it cost to make—before marketing, and ended up being the lowest opening Pixar movie in history.
The interesting part isn’t that Pixar played it safe. It’s that they remembered their roots. Once upon a time, the studio built its legacy on universal stories about toys, monsters, and feelings that connected with every child. The modern trend of turning animated films into political sermons has alienated families and eroded trust in a brand that once stood for imagination. By cutting the LGBTQ subplot, Docter may have inadvertently done more than salvage Elio. He drew a quiet line against the cultural feminization and ideological mission-creep turning kids’ entertainment into therapy sessions disguised as art.
When the politics fade and the story returns, that’s the real creative reset Pixar—and Hollywood—desperately needs.
***
Todd Fisher
Todd lives in Northern California with "the wife," "the kids," "the dogs," "that cat," and he occasionally wears pants. His upcoming release, "Are You Woke Enough Yet?", is the culmination of too much time on social media and working in the film industry.
English (US) · 