My home office is basically a shrine to Star Wars. Vintage figures, ships, posters, the whole thing. None of it impresses my kids. My teenage daughter would rather watch TikTok videos than sit through a single lightsaber duel. My youngest couldn’t care less about my Boba Fett statue or my original, framed 1977 Star Wars poster. My wife can’t even get the title right. She calls it “the new hope.” When I tried to show it to her, she got distracted talking about how everyone 70s hairstyles.
I think this is a perfect snapshot of what happens when a franchise has forgotten who it was built for. When Kathleen Kennedy took over Lucasfilm, the shift was obvious. The focus moved away from the nuts and bolts appeal of Star Wars that boys loved and into something softer, more abstract, and frankly less interesting to the core audience that made it a cultural force in the first place.
Here is the part Hollywood keeps refusing to understand. Boys did not fall in love with Star Wars because of mystical philosophy. They were not lining up to meditate on the Force. They wanted stormtroopers, bounty hunters, droids, blasters, ships, and anything that could explode or fly across a room at high speed. The Force was always there, but it was seasoning, not the meal.
Luke’s lightsaber mattered, sure. Kids swung those things around constantly. But Han Solo’s blaster was just as important. Boba Fett became a legend off a missile equipped jetpack and attitude. The Millennium Falcon was not a symbol. It was a clunky beather that needed fixing, flying, and fighting. That grounded, mechanical reality gave the fantasy weight. It made it feel usable, not preachy.
The modern version of this franchise leans hard in the opposite direction. It strips out the grit and replaces it with themes that feel more like a lecture than an adventure. You see it reflected in the lack of enthusiasm around newer releases and in the toy aisles where demand does not match what it used to be. You can call it evolution if you want, but audiences vote with their time and money, and those numbers tell a different story.
Turning Marvel and Star Wars into girl brands will prove to be one of the costliest decisions in entertainment history. https://t.co/Yazlxm9dHx
— Chris Gore (@ThatChrisGore) November 13, 2023
At the end of the day, this is not complicated. Males love the “Wars” in Star Wars. They want action, conflict, tools, and a world that runs on cause and effect. They will use the Force, but they are going to use it to throw something, break something, or win a fight. Nobody is showing up for space meditation unless it helps blow something up faster. The Force might be framed as something gentle and internal now, but fixing the Falcon, firing the blaster, and surviving the fight has always been the point. When you trade that for messaging and call it progress, you do not expand the audience. You lose it.
***
English (US) · 