‘The Witcher’ Season 4’s Stunning Visuals Can’t Hide the Soulless Slop

The arrival of Season 4 of The Witcher on Netflix brings the departure of Henry Cavill and the arrival of Liam Hemsworth as the lead character Geralt of Rivia. What stood out in previous seasons was Cavill’s gravelly voice and commanding presence, setting a high bar for the monster hunter. Hemsworth steps in with the difficult task of filling those boots, but the result is a series that feels disjointed rather than revitalized. This season offers plenty of visual effects and new characters, but it fails to deliver the focused storytelling the show once promised.

Season 4 follows Geralt, Yennefer, and Ciri on separate, complicated paths across a war-torn continent. The narrative attempts to juggle several genres at once — fantasy, war drama, political intrigue, and even a touch of melodrama. Instead of creating a coherent story, the show ends up overwhelmed by its own ambitions, making it hard to keep up with motivations or care about outcomes. Key characters wobble between moments of strength and inexplicable vulnerability. For example, Geralt shifts from an unstoppable force to someone easily restrained. Yennefer’s storyline dips into caricature, introducing a witch figure who seems disconnected from her original character. Ciri’s arc with the gang called the Rats swings between gritty and cartoonish, trading the dark symbolism of the books for something closer to teenage rebellion.

The bigger issue is not Hemsworth’s performance, which is adequate and brings some new vulnerability to Geralt. Cavill’s embodiment of the role was undeniable, but Hemsworth does just enough to keep the character alive on screen. The supporting cast, including Anya Chalotra as Yennefer and Freya Allan as Ciri, still have strong moments, and Laurence Fishburne’s addition as Regis adds some depth. Yet, all this talent can’t mask the script’s unfocused approach and clunky pacing.

The political and military conflicts unfold off-screen too often, reducing epic struggles to cramped scenes that lack the grandeur and clarity expected from a high-budget fantasy. The show’s production values remain high, with elaborate costumes and effective monster design, but the polish cannot hide the weak script that never decides what it wants to be.

In sum, The Witcher without Cavill is a mess. The show’s refusal to find a narrative center turns it into an overstuffed spectacle lacking impact. Hemsworth’s Geralt does not destroy the role, but he also does not save what is fast becoming a visually impressive but narratively hollow disappointment. Season 4 looks good but feels like soulless slop at its core.

***