The trailer for Spider-Noir has finally dropped, and fans are buzzing with questions about who Nicolas Cage is really playing in the upcoming Prime Video series. Many are asking if the dark and gritty hero in this new show is the same one Cage voiced in the animated Spider-Verse movies. The short answer? No, he isn’t. But the reason why might surprise you.
On the surface, Spider-Noir looks almost identical to Spider-Man Noir. Even their names sound like twins. To make things more confusing, both are played by Nicolas Cage. But the key difference is who these heroes actually are. Cage’s character in Spider-Noir isn’t Peter Parker at all. His name is Ben Reilly, and longtime comic readers might recognize that name as the Scarlet Spider—a clone of Peter Parker.
So what does that mean for the show? For one, this new character doesn’t even call himself Spider-Man. He is simply “the Spider,” a grim figure patrolling the streets instead of swinging through skylines with teenage optimism. Producer Chris Miller addressed this in an interview with Esquire, saying, “Peter Parker feels synonymous with a high school kid. Boyish, on the way up.” He explained that Cage’s new version is “older and jaded,” and the new name fits that tone much better. In other words, this man has already seen what power and responsibility can do and he’s not out to learn lessons anymore.
By moving away from the Peter Parker identity, Spider-Noir opens the door to explore a darker story. The series leans into the harsh shadows of 1940s detective tales, where heroes get bruised, morality blurs, and not everything tied up in webs gets saved. Would the same story work if the lead was called Peter Parker? Probably not. That version of Spider-Man feels too bright for the world Prime Video is building here.
Some fans hoped Spider-Noir would connect directly to Cage’s Spider-Verse character. It would have been a nice continuity link, but it would also create a problem. The Spider-Verse films are animated, and when they showcase characters from other franchises, those heroes always appear in their original mediums. In other words, an animated Spider-Man stays animated. A live-action universe demands its own rules, and Spider-Noir is keen to establish those from the start.
The bottom line is that Prime Video isn’t just resurrecting Cage’s old Spider persona—it’s reinventing it. A new world, a new name, and a new kind of hero built for a tougher time. We’ll see just how far this darker version swings when Spider-Noir premieres on May 27, 2026. Until then, fans are left wondering: will this be the Spider-Man story they’ve been waiting for, or something entirely different?
***
English (US) · 