For years, Marvel Studios could do no wrong. Every new film was a guaranteed hit. But now? The cracks have been showing, and the box office numbers don’t lie.
According to a new report from Variety, Captain America: Brave New World ended 2025 as Marvel’s biggest financial flop. The so-called blockbuster made only $415 million worldwide on a $180 million budget. With marketing and reshoots, that’s a lot of money burned for little reward. Is the Marvel magic finally fading?
For context, Marvel’s Thunderbolts* didn’t do much better, bringing in about $370 million. That movie reportedly cost the same to make, plus another $100 million for advertising. And yet, The Fantastic Four: First Steps—the third Marvel movie of 2025—actually turned a profit, earning around $521 million. Same brand, same studio. So what happened with Captain America?
You could say the problem started long before the first frame rolled. Captain America: Brave New World was delayed multiple times, went through several reshoots, and listed five different writers in the final credits. When a movie changes that much behind the scenes, what chance does it have in theaters? Audiences can smell creative confusion a mile away.
This latest entry tried to juggle too many storylines, including a throwback to 2008’s The Incredible Hulk. Good luck keeping that straight. Viewers showed up expecting an inspiring story about a new Captain America and got a political thriller built around yet another government cover-up. Maybe the fans just aren’t buying it anymore. Maybe they’re tired of recycled plots and corporate messaging disguised as entertainment.
It’s telling that this is now the second-lowest-grossing Captain America movie ever made, and the seventh-worst performer in the entire Marvel Cinematic Universe. Remember, this is supposed to be one of Disney’s crown jewels. Even with big names like Anthony Mackie, Harrison Ford, and Giancarlo Esposito, audiences stayed home. Could it be that people have had enough of blockbuster assembly lines?
Still, Marvel isn’t done trying. The studio is betting on Spider-Man: Brand New Day this summer, hoping Tom Holland’s return will bring fans back. And in December, Avengers: Doomsday is expected to deliver the kind of box-office thunder Disney badly needs. But after what happened last year, can anyone really feel confident?
Marvel once built an empire by giving fans stories they believed in. Now, those same fans are walking away. What changed? Maybe Hollywood finally pushed too far, too fast. Or maybe the audience just woke up and decided it was time to stop paying for what feels like déjà vu with a billion-dollar price tag.
***
English (US) · 